Monday, November 28, 2016

CFTU Warns China Foreign ESL & TEFL Teachers of 379 New "Black Ghost' Schools Cloning Themselves With Alias Names!

Are You Looking For:

China Foreign Teacher Requirements         Breaking A China Teacher Contract

Although we do our best to keep you up-to-date about all the white and blacklisted schools operating in China, you need to be aware that the clever scammers we try to expose are not stupid. Once we out them, they usually just change their names and continue to recruit newbie ESL & TEFL teachers, or even veterans who may be too busy or too lazy to do their due diligence on Google & Yahoo. 

We recently met with officials from SAFEA and the China Scam Patrol to compare our lists of bad apples presenting themselves online under a variety of names recently created or adapted from names already exposed as frauds. For Example, CHINA ESL which is owned and operated by veteran scam artist Rebecca Tang in Beijing, now operates with 12 different alias names and uses no less than five foreign teachers to front for her.

So we are making a concentrated effort to recompile and update our blacklists, while every year 4-10 new entities wise up and fly straight so they can be white-listed.  On January 1, 2017 we will update our blacklist and on January 15th our white list.  For now, here are new addittions to the blacklist for those who may be looking for a new China employer over the next month. REMEMBER, these are just new addittions, so be sure to check the complete list at Also if you want to be extra careful, you can also check the China Liars List at and at as well.

Blacklisted Addittions
Holy Global Education (Beijing)
Gao Si Education (Beijing)
Cambridge Global Education (Beijing)
Mayflower Education (Beijing)
Champion Education (Beijing)
Lake English aka Lake ESL (Beijing)
Focus Education (Beijing)
New World ESL
China ESL World
Bole Education (Chong Qing)
RMD International aka Zhouwen International Culture Excchange
Hongren English
Hopen ESL 
Wiseway Global Education, aka Wiseway ESL aka Wiseway Education

Newly Added Black Agents & Recruiters
Global Teachers
Sail ESL aka New Sailing aka New Sailing ESL
Eric Winder
ESL Insider

These entities below were submitted to us by China Scam Patrol and they are all on our 2016 blacklist:

Angelinas ESL Café
Adam Wang
Alice Chang
Monica Chang
Monica Cheng aka ESLReady aka ESL Ready
Eric Winder
TEFL Panda
New Talent Academy
Hongren English
Holy Flower English aka ESLinsider aka ESL Insider
Amanda Li aka Amanda Liu aka Amanda Liao
China ESL
Lucky English
Worlda English aka Worlda International Education aka Worlda Cultural Services

i-to-i (online TEFL scam) (same online scam from UK)
Rebecca Tang
Expertise Education
Buckland Education Group
ABC Cowboy English
Focus Education
CCIE aka Terry Tong aka Tong Tong
Qianshi Technology Group (many alias names)
Michael Cavill aka Michael Cavhill aka Michael Cavell aka DFEA
David Valley
Derek Yazwa
Aston English
Deric Yazwa
Panda Visa
Golden Bridge
New Life ESL
New World ESL
China International ESL
China Horizons
China Pathways
China Wave
Sino English
Wise Way Global Education
Yuri Khlystov
Ben Tsao aka Ben Cao
Bi-Lingo China aka China Bi-Lingo
Lake Education aka Luke Education
American Christian School
Max Gen Education
Stanford English
Oxbridge aka aka
Charlie Chan aka Charlie Chang aka Charlie Cheng
Happy English
Owen English aka Ou Wen aka Oh Wen
Golden Tran Education
Carl Ge aka Carle He
Peter Zheng aka Ying Tian Zheng aka Zheng Tian Ying
Maple Leaf English
Disney English (Some Beijing & Chengdu locations only)
Disney Education Group
Jenny Wu aka Jenny Woo
Christina Zhang aka Christina Chang
Crystal Li
ABC English
EZ English
English Express
Danny Zhou aka Danny Chen

If you ignore these warnings and choose to work with one of these shadow or "Black Ghost" schools, this is what you can expect: 

As always, we reccomend that you apply directly with white-listed schools and only those who are listed in the SAFEA's current directory and who can give you an invitation for a Z VISA in the same name that appears on their SAIC license.

Sunday, November 13, 2016

229 China Foreign Teachers Arrested in Latest PSB "Twitter Trap" Sting Operation

Were you looking for...

Although information is scarce at this time, a contact at the PSB has leaked that 229 foreign teachers working in China were arrested in th elast 30 days for working illegally without a Z Visa in Beijing and Shanghai.  At first the CSP was told the number was 29 teachers but we learned yesterday that was a miscommunication.

What we learned so far from China Scam Patrol confirms the above leak since they learned a black ESL agent in Beijing using a Twitter Account was pretending to be a "happy ESL teacher in  China earning over $50,000 a year." This fake account was recommending others on Twitter to "contact the recruiter that made it all possible" at yet another Twitter account.  Well some how the PSB got wind of this scam and went after the guy we know as "Guo Bin" since he was falsely telling everyone who contacted him on Twitter that they could work in China without a Z visa (work visa) nor a university degree (absolutely false)

The scam back-fired on the scammer when the PSB sent someone to a job interview posing as a foreign teacher and wearing a hidden microphone. Long story short, the recruiter was arrested as were some the foreign teachers whose resumes they found in his briefcase. Things snow-balled from there...

Those arrested were given a choice... go to jail for 30 days or pay a fine and allow the PSB to copy their phone contacts. Herein lies the real problem as now thousands of foreign teachers working in China are probably going to be collected into a PSB database from the 229  arrested teachers - assuming they opt not to go to jail for 30 days.  IF these names obtained from all the phones collected by the PSB are used for either a "random visa or diploma check", there may another 1,000 or so teachers finding themselves in a sudden legal jam.  Of course the PSB might be a bit lazy during the upcoming holidays, but in the last 2 years they have been quite diligent and zealous in their efforts.  

The bottom line is that those of you working in China with a legal Z visa and a real diploma have nothing to fear. If however you are not holding a Z visa now and are using a fake diploma, you stand more than a 50% chance of getting caught within the next 45 days, especially if you used agents and recruiters who used the following names; Guo Bin, Ying, Ming, Ling, Li Peng, Rebecca Tang, Derrick Yazwa, Bing, Keith, Erica Lau aka Erica Liu, Miranda, Carl He, Rose Li, Owen, Henry, or if you ever sent resumes to ESL Insider, TheBeijinger, EChinacities, Sinocities, ESLCafe (going back to July of 2016). This information is current as of November 10th, 2016 and relates to arrests made prior to November 7th. We can assume that those arrested will identify their recruiters & agents and they will probably also be tracked down and their phones also copied.  So the best advice we can offer is for illegal teachers now working in China, to take a voluntarily leave of absence and get yourself legal with the proper visas before returning to work.  

If you do get arrested and jailed, you can expect to spend 10-30 days in jail depending upon how much you "cooperate" with the Chinese aurhorities and fines are ranging from $2,000 to $5,000. You WILL be deported within 30 days with a reentry ban of 3 to 5 years. Unfortunately, if you are studying in China, you will not be allowed to finish your studies, and from our past experience, you will not be able to get a refund of your tuition moneys.  

If you are detained, try to remain calm and do not argue or shout at the authorities. They will treat you professionally, feed you, and allow you to make a telephone call. Do not waste it calling your agent or recruiter. They will not help you. Call your nearest family member or friend in China who can pay your fine.

At present we know that the Twitter Traps are working so well for the PSB, that they may also start using Facebook. Last year they were exposed placing fake job ads on, Craiglist, Glassdoor, Echinacities, Sinocities, and ESLCafe. Our PSB source tells us that they get a 2,000 yuan pay bonus for every illegal foreigner they catch working in China, and that is why they really are taking this matter to heart since 2,000 yuan is one-third of their monthly salary.

This new sting operation is in addittion to their other major method of rounding up illegal alien workers in China as you can read here:

Tuesday, August 23, 2016

Good News - China Foreign TEFL & ESL Teachers Average Monthly Pay For 2016 Increased to 18,000 for Native English Speakers


With the demand for TEFL and ESL teachers at an all time high in China, recruiters and schools were forced to finally offer more attractive compensation packages, especially for native English speakers which now are getting paid between 16,000 yuan to 22,000 yuan per month in addition to air fare reimbursements, paid  30 day vacation, and medical insurance packages. Roughly half of the private schools and training centers are also offering 10,000 yuan annual bonus upon the completion of your contract. Should you hold an degree in Education, you can command a monthly salary of up to 30,000 yuan per  month at an International school.
Kindergarten teachers with experience can expect to earn an average of 20,000 per month if your previous experience is verifiable with release letters and some references.
Non-native English speakers can expect an average of 12,000 per month for full-time positions. For more information on China pay scales for foreign teachers, please visit and remember to sign no contracts until AFTER checking our white list and blacklist and reading up at
WARNING:  If you have asthma or bad allergies, you should consult with your doctor before traveling to China. During winter months, pollution levels are frequently toxic.

Tuesday, June 7, 2016

IMPORTANT CFTU NOTICE: China Foreign Teachers Now Protected By Labor Laws & Privacy Act!


Things are getting better for foreign employees in China and it is getting more difficult for employers to exploit you. In 2014 China labor laws that favored Chinese employees were amended to apply to all employees in China (not interns) thanks to the good conscience of President Xi Jin Ping (Xie Xie Mr. President).  This year the Privacy Act was also expanded to include foreign employees. What does this mean for you?
Well for one thing no employer in China can use your image or give your personal information to any third party (a student's mother for example) without your written permission on a document that says who requested your information and why and how your information will be used IF you agree. If you do not agree, you cannot be punished in any way or the employer can be fined 100,000yuan or have their business license suspended for 90 days.

Blanket agreements in employment contracts are no longer legal. Off course, nobody is going to tell you this. But you can get free labor law updates at Renmin University Law School library and National Library, both in Haidian District of Beijing. Here is where you can read a summary of your 15 rights as an expat employee in China:
It is well worth 30 minutes of your time to know your rights as a China Foreign Teacher. Although we do not provide legal assistance or advice, we can recommend very qualified labor lawyers to you if you cannot resolve matters amicably, and we sincerely urge you to avoid the courts or you may find yourself blacklisted with Chinese principals. The blacklist is now illegal but still widely in use in Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou (also rumored to be used in Shenzhen and Shenyang as well)  Also be aware of the deadly "SILENT SCAM" that targets china foreign teachers...

The biggest scam going down against china foreign teachers is explained here so do not send your resume to job ads you find at Beijinger, Echinacities, ESLCafe, Sinocities, Gumtree, nor Craiglsist. Read this:
To be aware of all the latest china scams we suggest you visit and read these sites at least once a month as well as drop by for a visit here.

Monday, May 23, 2016

China to hire 12,000 more ESL & TEFL teachers for fall semester to compensate for mass exodus...



The Ministry of Education says their public schools are running short of experienced native English teachers and this is no mystery. Over the last three years over 20,000 veteran foreign China English teachers have left China for greener pastures in Sen ingapore, Korea and Japan where the pay is more than 70% higher on average - when adjusted for cost of living. Many of those leaving this year at the end of their contracts also cite the heavy air pollution they must endure during the four months of winter which seven foreign embassies have labeled "toxic".

Still, China's historical mystique continues to lure fresh faces every year and it is hoped that higher wages that now average 16,000 per month with a 2,000 yuan housing allowance will be enough to produce 12,000 native English speakers for Sept/2016 although we think this will be a true challenge.

For those who love history, great food, and want to learn Chinese and a whole new way of life, a one year contract in China may be just your ticket of you are at least 21 years of age with 2 years teaching experience and a bachelor degree in any subject. If you have a criminal record do not bother to apply. If however you are a native speaker you can demand wages of 20,000 yuan per month or even more at the private schools.

WORD OF WARNING:  China is full of scams, and most of them come from job recruiters who lure students to come work without a mandatory Z visa. There are also a few identity thieves that pose as schools or recruiters fishing for your personal data. Read these links to defend yourself accordingly:

Also feel free to check our annual white and blacklists at

Please do not write us asking about individual employers. We don't do your leg work on an individual basis. That is precisely why we have over 1,500 white-listed employers and over 500 on the blacklist. Get off your butt and read. And off course, do not come to China without a signed contract and Z visa already in your hand.  Last piece of advice:..

Monday, April 4, 2016

Who is trashing the CFTU and why? Relax you need not be Sherlock Holmes to figure this out!

Are You Looking For:

In the last 6 months, five China job recruiters that we exposed over the last two years have done their very best to smear us with all sorts of accusations, some of which were admittedly quite funny and even we had a good laugh.(ie the one about the United Nations wanted us all to be hanged!).  Actually to be honest, we take the derogatory comments as a compliment that we have been doing our job- exposing school and agent frauds, and giving useful information to our teaching colleagues already in China, as well as those inbound to China.

Here are some of the people who have attacked us and when you read the links you will understand why:

1. A moderator at Reddit whose day job is an unregistered china teacher job recruiter.

2. A former recruiter from Expertise Education named Stefan who was arrested for working with an illegal visa and advised many other newbie teachers to come work in China illegally with many unlicensed "black schools & learning centers".  This is his story and frankly we sympathized with the guy until he began saying we snitched on him to the authorities. We are foreigners- we don't snitch on fellow foreigners - period.  and also

3. A handful of users at Echinacities, eslcafe, and thebeijinger who were exposed over the last three years as unlicensed job recruiters who even sold your resumes to identity thieves for $30-$50 each! See

We noticed all these fake teachers masquerading as "fellow teachers" online about three years ago when this article was published.

All of these people have asked us to say only "nice things about China" and one even offered us $50,000 to do so. Why? Because they earn about $1,000 for every teacher they bring to China, whether they are qualified or not, and whether they are given legal visas or not, and whether the teachers get arrested or not. So long as the new teachers do not get caught within the first 90 days, the agents get paid. The odds are in favor of the agents- at least for those first 90 days. Then it become a 50/50 situation.  Anyway, we turned down the $50,000 and we continue to publish the truth,like these links for examples:

We have been sharing these scam alerts and our white and blacklists since 2010 and we will continue to do so until all the unethical agents still remaining clean-up their acts.  We also provide training, welcome packages,and social activities - all of which is free. Even our membership is free. We do not sell any product nor service, nor advertising. We do not endorse anything,and we have never been sued for any reason. So the next time someone suggests we are cheating someone, please demand the details of who and how was anyone ever cheated by us in any way.

Now then, if you need to breakout of a crappy one-sided contract, find a better-paying safe employer, negotiate a fair contract, or get your last paycheck or release letter, just scroll and search through our 89 posts in our archives, or use google, and you will find six years of hard work on your behalf.

Thankfully,over 90% of the email we receive indicates our colleagues appreciate our work. If we can be doing something better, please just let us know. I am Gregg Finch, the Administrator and you can reach me at

Please understand that we receive about 300 inquiries every day from all over the world and we operate only with a volunteer staff. So if you are not a member it may take us more than a week to reply to you. Our members get 24 hour service. Thank you for your understanding and patience. As I sign off for now I leave you with one question... Are YOU earning at least 250 yuan per hour teaching in China? If not - please read this here:

As foreign teachers in China, we feel a moral obligation to look out for one another. Please help us do this if you agree.

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Beware of illegal Z visa China Foreign Teachers teaching ESL & TEFL - You can easily get arrested and deported.

Are You Looking For:

If you used an agent to find a ESL or TEFL teaching job in China, there is a 33% chance your Z visa is NOT legal - even if it is real. What!?!  Yes, as bizarre as this may sound to you, here is what is going on and 80% of foreign teachers in China do not even know about this.
If your real true employer is not registered with SAFEA and SAIC they may be what is called a "black school" or "black learning center" (you can check our 2016 blacklist to check at they probably gave you an invitation letter from another company who is properly registered and legitimate. Although this is illegal it has been done for years and only a few dozen teachers were actually caught and deported. HOWEVER, following some bad behavior incidents of foreign teachers, the Chinese government is now doing their best to weed out all the many fake teachers in China who may never have taught anything, used a fake diploma to apply for their visa, or are working on the wrong visa. Last year they arrested and deported over 2,100 expat teachers who "faked" their way into China.

So this year the PSB is on a mission to scrutinize all 31,000+ visa applications of the foreigners now teaching in China as well as all the incoming new comers. THEY ARE NOW MATCHING INVITATION LETTERS TO YOUR ACTUAL EMPLOYER.
If there is not a match, you will get a friendly visit but even your best smile and Chinese language skills will not save you from being arrested, jailed and deported.

If the company, red seal, and SAIC business license all match with your real employer, you have nothing to worry about mate. If you are not sure how to check, you can email us a scan of your invitation letter, and the name of your actual employer and we can let you know within 2 weeks if your Z visa is legal or not - in strict confidence. of course. If you have an illegal Z visa you have three choices;
1) You can demand that your employer fix the problem with the proper Z visa (only possible if they are approved and registered with SAFEA)

2) You can quickly search out another white-listed employer who can hire you with the correct Z visa before your current visa expires - or you get caught.

3) You can simply depart China voluntarily on your own before you get caught and banned, and then reenter with a proper Z visa from a legitimate employer.

At present it is estimated that one-third of all Z visas issued are illegal. We urge you to check yours today. If you want our help with verification we ask that you first check our blacklist first at If you do not see your school listed, then please send us the scan of your invitation letter to help[at]China Since our members get priority attention, you may have to wait up to two weeks for a reply. Thank you for your patience. You may also want to learn about other China scams at

Monday, March 7, 2016

China Foreign Teacher Survey Has Surprises For CFTU Staff...

Are You Looking For:

Every year we take an annual survey in order to compile our white and blacklists and to get an idea of the biggest concerns, gripes, and worries of our teaching colleagues in China. The 2015 annual survey results were compiled and here are some interesting finds we now share with you...
* 62% of those surveyed say they will not be staying another year in China for one of three reasons;
-  Toxic Pollution
-  Hepatitis Epidemic
-  Pay is better elsewhere with less scams
*  Only 18% of teachers used agents to find their teaching positions in 2015
*  29% admitted to working illegally without a Z visa or a fake diploma
*  59% claimed they were cheated by their employer at least once (mostly private schools)
*  Average full-time monthly salary for a native English speaker in China in 2015 was 16,500 yuan
*  Average office hours required in 2015 was 15 hours with 20 classroom hours
*  Average age of China foreign teachers jumped to 25 years.
*  67% of China foreign teachers said they are "mostly satisfied" with their job
*  79% said they do not trust job ads at ESLCafe, Beijinger, nor EChinacities/Sinocities
*  28% said they earn over 40,000 per month doing private tutoring
*  43% said they use the CFTU white list and 82% said they use our blacklist
*  The most complaints we received were 39 against a single agency, and 28 against a school
*  68% of China expat teachers are male and 52% come from America, 12% from Canada, 18% from the Ukraine, 10% from Australia, and 8% from the UK
*  The large chains like Wall Street, EF, Webb, Disney, had the highest turn-over rates
*   The most "unacceptable chain" employer was Disney English, which also had the second highest number of teachers arrested for working illegally.

BTW... did you know the following facts:

<> You have rights as a foreign employee that are the same as Chinese professionals if you hold a Z visa and FEC.  See here for details...

<> 1,978 foreign expat teachers were arrested and deported from China last year for working without a Z visa and 482 were deported for working with fake university diplomas.

<> There are now only 122 legally licensed and registered HR job agents (head hunters) operating in China nationwide and all have an SAIC license they can show you. If you cannot obtain a color scan of their SAIC business license they are black scam operation to be avoided. There are 322 "black" China job agents (that we know of at this time)

<> The five most trusted and used ESL/TEFL forums used by China foreign teachers are,,,, and

The top 3 complaints from China foreign teachers in 2015 were:

1)  Last paycheck was not paid
2)  Contract not honored
3)  Lies about Visas
4)  Release letter not given
5)  Employer turned out to be illegal employer

NOTICE:  The CFTU is not allowed to provide legal advice, and we have very limited resources. So if you are not a member and you need help or information, you must be patient if you send us an email. Our 6,129 members get our priority attention. Our volunteer staff does the best we can so please scroll through our web site and the welcome package we will send you by email for the information you need. We do not investigate or "check" schools on an individual request basis - especially if you are not a member. Thank you for your understanding, cooperation, and support. If you wish to report an illegal school, agent, or company that holds your passport, or hired you without a Z visa, or refuses to provide you a copy of their license or a release letter, please send us an email at report[at]

Monday, February 15, 2016

Chinese PSB authorities will arrest and deport any China Foreign ESL or TEFL Teacher caught using a fake diploma or TEFL Certificate in 2016

You need to know that  more than 90% of the online job ads are scams and deliberately do not tell applicants that they MUST have a REAL  bachelor degree and a Z visa (work visa).  They only tell the newbie wannabe foreign teacher what they want them to know. Why?
Because aside from the $500 placement fee the agent collects from the school, they will sell a fake diploma to any applicant who doesn't have one, and then offer and obtain for them a 90 day "F" or "L" visa which will get the new teacher into the country, but give them a 50% chance of arrest as this below post from China Scam Patrol explains quite well...

"China to deport 3,000 illegal foreign teachers for fake diplomas and wrong visas"


This may be good or bad news for you depending if you are one of the 20,000 foreigners legally teaching in China or one of the 10,000 expats who used fake diplomas or TEFL certificates to get your visa to work in China.
We were recently "unofficially" advised that a new 500 member PSB task force will be launched on March 1, 2016 to hunt down, arrest, and deport any expat teacher using false documents (or who doesn't have a valid Z visa) This will be a nation-wide sweep according to a Captain I the PSB whose true name was not given although we inspected his government credentials when he agreed to a secret 90 minute interview we waited six months to get.
How will they find the fake teachers? In short, any way they can! But the Captain said they would...
1. Expand the sting operations that proved successful in arresting over 3,000 expats in 2014 and 2015 with more fake job ads and even setting up booths at job fairs in major China cities.
2. Copy cell phone and email data from every black China job agent they arrest or question.
3. By promoting their existing "Reward Program" that pays 10,000 yuan to anyone who turns in a fake foreign teacher
4. Monitoring emails of foreigners that contain red flag words like "replica", "fake", "reproduction" as well as "fake", "genuine", and "diploma" and "certificate".
5. Resume reviews conducted randomly at schools and principals who refuse to cooperate will be fined 50,000 rmb per violation.
He also alluded to a new set of tricks and traps that have not been used yet, but somehow it will involve an email and Skype marketing campaign, perhaps of a school that really does not exist.
What created this new PSB zeal?  Over 2,000 complaints to the Minister of Education from angry mothers, one of whom happened to be the wife of a Mayor whose kid was being tutored by a girl who turned out to be using a fake diploma from NYU! Thanks to Wei Xin, that story spurred a bunch of written complaints and yet other mothers complained about 3 dozen Chinese "International Schools" and companies falsely claiming to be "partners" and "affiliates" of China's Ministry of Education.
Now the jig is up, and if you are not working legally in China, now would be a great time for you to take a "leave of absence" and exit voluntarily so you are not deported as a convict felon. For those of you working within the Chinese law you will soon have a great reason to ask for a raise because the PSB captain said they will not stop until they reach their annual quota of 3,000 expat deportations. The below links relate to over 5,000 previous deportations of foreign teachers from China: